Okay, I have to start by being very clear. I read this book and
reviewed it after being given an ebook copy by the author. I don't
personally know the author other than through this website. I
agreed to read and review the book because of the recent kerfluffle
about other reviews on this site. What you are about to read is my
honest opinion of this book (with hopefully a minimal amount of
spoilers).....
A Child's Wound is a decent freshman effort by a new Canadian
author. I guess it would best be classified as a thriller, but the
thrills are lukewarm. It's not edge of your seat, but it's a solid
read.
Tim, is a serial killer/rapist. He's the anti-hero of the story
that almost makes you want to like him - if only he didn't rape
women as a way to feel powerful and mask his feelings of inadequacy
and helplessness. He likes to stalk his victims and get to 'know'
them first. He has a gameplan he likes to follow. But while he is
currently molding his latest victim, he's stalking the next, only
there is something different about Christine.
Christine, is a homocide detective working on the Picasso serial
killer case. The so-called Picasso killer, has earned his name by
horrifically mutilating his victims and staging them like works of
art. Christine and her partner, Jefferies, have been on the case
for months but things are beginning to look like they might finally
be getting a break. When a washed up FBI agent muscles his way on
to the case, Christine is less than happy, but since she has no say
in the matter, she makes the best of it. At least her social life
is looking up, having literally bumped into Tim, who seems like a
terrific guy, at her local coffeeshop.
While this book was interesting enough to keep me turning pages, it
didn't give me that rollercoaster thrillride. There were definitely
some parts where I just had to go huh? Why would he/she/they do
that? The main thing I had problems with is that Tim's appeal, and
his ability to get Simone to do the things she does, is not
adequately explained. I was left to assume that Simone is damaged
herself and twisted enough that Tim's 'attentions' appeal to her
and the reason she is willing to go along with Tim is that she is a
psychopath herself.
Kavanagh's writing style is easy to read, although some of the
transitions from one POV to another or from scene to scene felt a
little choppy. There were also some timeframe and procedural
inconsistencies that while not a big deal, did sort of jump out at
me. Neither 'complaint' is unexpected for a first time author,
especially one that has not been published by a big name publisher
and so probably didn't have the assistance of a detail-oriented
editor.
Where I found this story the most lacking is that while there were
two interesting sub-plots, neither was really developed to it's
fullest potential. There was no real thrill of the hunt for the
killer because you already know one, and the other is evident
pretty quickly. This is not a police procedural, the focus is not
Christine the cop, but rather Tim the psychopath. The actual
investigation into either killer is really secondary. And, when the
two sub-plots converge at the end, I have to say I found the ending
and the decision made by Christine very disappointing and totally
out of character for her. Towards the end, when a standoff between
the two killers became apparent I was envisioning a much different
ending.
Finally, some reviews have played up the sexual nature of the
crimes in the book, but I feel that they are doing the book a
disservice. Yes, the crimes are horrific, no rape is not sexy, and
I don't believe that this is the author's goal. The scenes are not
sensationalized and I have read more graphic descriptions of murder
and rape reading JD Robb or JA Konrath.
2010-056