Fall on Your Knees

by Ann-marie Macdonald

Knopf Canada | December 6, 1998 | Trade Paperback

Based on 520 ratings | Rate this
"What a wild ride - I couldn't turn the pages fast enough," Oprah Winfrey told her viewers as she announced Fall on Your Knees as her February 2002 Book Club selection. Set largely in a Cape Breton coal mining community called New Waterford, ranging through four generations, Ann-Marie MacDonald's dark, insightful and hilarious first novel focuses on the Piper sisters and their troubled relationship with their father, James. Winner of the 1997 Commonwealth Writers Prize for Best First Book, it was a national bestseller in Canada for two years, and it has been translated into 17 languages.

At the start of the 20th century, James Piper sets fire to his dead mother's piano and heads out across Cape Breton Island to find a new place to live, eventually eloping with 13-year-old Materia Mahmoud, the daughter of wealthy, traditional Lebanese parents. And so, from early on, Ann-Marie MacDonald establishes some major themes: racial tension, isolation, passion and forbidden love, which will gradually lead to incest, death in childbirth, and even murder. At the centre of this epic story is the nature of family love, beginning with the Piper sister who depend on one another for survival. Their development as characters - beautiful Kathleen, the promising diva; saintly Mercedes; Frances, the mischievous bad girl, who tries to bear the family's burden; and disabled Lily, everyone's favourite - forms the heart of the novel. And then there is James, their flawed father.

Moving from Cape Breton Island to the battlefields of World War I, to Harlem in New York's Jazz Age and the Depression, the tense and enthralling plot of Fall on Your Knees contains love, pain, death, joy, and triumph. The structure of the narrative is multi-faceted, richly layered, and shifts back and forth through time as it approaches the story from different angles, "giving it a mythic quality that allows dark, half buried secrets to be gracefully and chillingly revealed" (The New York Times Book Review). As the details of the labyrinthine plot are pulled together, the question of whether it is possible to escape one's family history gradually raises itself.

The book's epigraph, taken from Wuthering Heights, seems appropriate to a novel concerned with the different, often violent, forms that love can take. On the inexorable journey towards tragedy we encounter dark yet vivid images of neglect and violence, yet the novel radiates an unquenchable life-force, and yet the novel radiates an unquenchable life-force, shimmering with emotional depth, sensual with virtuoso descriptions of the power of music. It is a saga haunted by ghosts and saints, religious fanaticism and magic. MacDonald gives the most ordinary lives extraordinarily dramatic dimensions.

The Sunday Times wrote, "It is the unpredictability of this huge book that is its greatest joy." With allusions ranging from Hollywood stars to religious tracts, Fall on Your Knees simmers with vibrancy and crackling, effervescent, breathtaking language.
In Stock
This item is eligible for FREE SHIPPING.
See details
save 24%

$17.48

was $23.00

$16.61

Member Price

or, Used from $5.04

add to cart
add to wish list add to gift list
Found in: Fiction and Literature

All reviews of Fall on Your Knees

1 2 3 4 5 6
  • Was this review helpful?
    2
    3
    Hard to finish
    by SM
    7 months ago

    This book was disappointing. It did not hold my interest. I was quite fed up with it about half way through and I only finished it because I was traveling in a remote area and it was my only option. I felt nothing but relief when I finished this book.

    Comments on this review:
    Kendra Raine

    This was my exact experience! I took this book on a beach holiday with me - and like you it was my only one as it was so long. I finished and left it in the sand with the hope that it would just disappear from my life!

  • Was this review helpful?
    3
    0
    I was a little disappointed.
    by LibraryCin
    • Top Book Reviewer
    18 months ago

    3.25 stars It is the early 1900s in Nova Scotia. 13-year old Materia falls for James, so she breaks away from her arranged marriage her parents have made for her and marries James, only to be disowned by her parents. James dotes on their first daughter, Kathleen and though, years later, they have more daughters, their marriage turns sour. The book not only follows them, but follows their daughters during their lives. I was a little disappointed. I really liked The Way the Crow Flies, but for me, this wasn't nearly as interesting. It didn't grab me or hold my interest. I really didn't like any of the characters, which always makes it harder for me to enjoy a book. I wasn't compelled to pick up the book and/or to keep reading. Overall, I thought it was o.k., but nothing special.

  • Eilythea Senis

    Was this review helpful?
    1
    5
    Non fiction truth in a fictional world
    by Eilythea Senis
    3 years ago

    This novel may possibly be the key hole to many of our silenced victims’ lives, whether they’ve been consumed by unwanted penetration, bewildered, hindered from accomplishing equality, and brought down to desperation to the full extent; even without knowing it. Fall On Your Knees is an incredibly written fiction in which history, culture, and the hidden disturbances of social issues, have been composed into one. It can be difficult to comprehend, and attempting to soak up each word may take courage. For the willing eyes that seek to discover the non fiction’s secret truths in a fictional world, it is best to be warned to open up your mind before opening the pages that expose humanity’s filth. Without an open mind, it is guaranteed to injure the mind of one that is weak. It is not advised to read the novel as casual. The key to reading one that exposes the human world takes a lot of comprehension, dissection, and evaluation. In order to survive a novel that holds so much, it is best to keep your logic on guard, while your emotions are kept tamed. In refusing to do so, it would not be a surprise to find yourself unable to cope with the mental disturbances and emotional grievances you’ve welcomed by not reading it with a controlled heart and careful eyes. pg 375 One would consider this as perverted. But only those with perverted minds would look over these passages again and again constantly while quoting it without a purpose. There is purpose in what Ann-Marie has written in this excerpt from the book. Hurt, heaviness and hate was the goal of this passage. She intended to cause her audience to be appalled, abashed, and abhorred. Not only was she genius in doing so, but she included a response in which her character “Frances” has comforted her watchful sister after the incident. This response, in which a 6 year old has assured to her slightly older sister, was well composed to cause heartbreak in her audience. "I keep looking at each other until he falls asleep like that, then she crawls out from behind his arms and walks over to me. 'It doesn’t hurt', she says." - pg. 376 The author, Ann-Marie Macdonald has obviously put a lot of thought in this novel. Palpably enough, it is blatant that Ann-Marie has been careful to select the right words, and combine them together to create the impact she has intended it to be. If put into a symbolic image, Fall On Your Knees is like an immaculate white house. It shines, and sparkles. But everyone that passes by it does not feel the innocence the house is supposed to hold present. And if one dares to enter, they find that the white house is not as immaculate as it imitates itself to be. Instead, past the sturdy bricks of white, you see that the paint is peeling off, and inside the house it is nothing but dusty and bloody. There are no people, but it is not empty; it is haunted.

  • Eilythea Senis

    Was this review helpful?
    2
    1
    Compelling
    by Eilythea Senis
    3 years ago

    This novel may possibly be the key hole to many of our silenced victims’ lives, whether they’ve been consumed by unwanted penetration, bewildered, hindered from accomplishing equality, and brought down to desperation to the full extent; even without knowing it. Fall On Your Knees is an incredibly written fiction in which history, culture, and the hidden disturbances of social issues, have been composed into one. It can be difficult to comprehend, and attempting to soak up each word may take courage. For the willing eyes that seek to discover the non fiction’s secret truths in a fictional world, it is best to be warned to open up your mind before opening the pages that expose humanity’s filth. Without an open mind, it is guaranteed to injure the mind of one that is weak. It is not advised to read the novel as casual. The key to reading one that exposes the human world takes a lot of comprehension, dissection, and evaluation. In order to survive a novel that holds so much, it is best to keep your logic on guard, while your emotions are kept tamed. In refusing to do so, it would not be a surprise to find yourself unable to cope with the mental disturbances and emotional grievances you’ve welcomed by not reading it with a controlled heart and careful eyes. pg.375 One would consider this as perverted. But only those with perverted minds would look over these passages again and again constantly while quoting it without a purpose. There is purpose in what Ann-Marie has written in this excerpt from the book. Hurt, heaviness and hate was the goal of this passage. She intended to cause her audience to be appalled, abashed, and abhorred. Not only was she genius in doing so, but she included a response in which her character “Frances” has comforted her watchful sister after the incident. This response, in which a 6 year old has assured to her slightly older sister, was well composed to cause heartbreak in her audience. "I keep looking at each other until he falls asleep like that, then she crawls out from behind his arms and walks over to me. 'It doesn’t hurt', she says." - pg. 376 The author, Ann-Marie Macdonald has obviously put a lot of thought in this novel. Palpably enough, it is blatant that Ann-Marie has been careful to select the right words, and combine them together to create the impact she has intended it to be. If put into a symbolic image, Fall On Your Knees is like an immaculate white house. It shines, and sparkles. But everyone that passes by it does not feel the innocence the house is supposed to hold present. And if one dares to enter, they find that the white house is not as immaculate as it imitates itself to be. Instead, past the sturdy bricks of white, you see that the paint is peeling off, and inside the house it is nothing but dusty and bloody. There are no people, but it is not empty; it is haunted.

  • Was this review helpful?
    3
    0
    Complex, intricate, haunting & dark story
    by Karen
    3 years ago

    This is a book I will not forget and am happy I decided to pick it up despite my initial hesitance (being an Oprah's pick). While I found this book a bit hard to get into and didn't think I would like it at first, I cam out of it saying - Wow - a very complex, intricate, haunting and dark story that could only be written by a very talented author. My initial thoughts about not attaching to the book where because I wouldn't say the characters are likeable - I didn't bond or relate to them as in other favourite books - but I became memorized by them and compelled to attempt to understand what drove them in their actions and beliefs. In the end a book of love, family, survival and struggle, but in the most unique of ways. A book difficult to describe - you have to read it to understand.

  • Jillian Curtin

    Was this review helpful?
    1
    0
    One Of The Best Pieces Of FIction Around
    by Jillian Curtin
    3 years ago

    This has to be one of the best books every written. I fell in love with all of the Piper girls...Frances Piper I believe is one of the greatest female characters in Canadian literature. I devoured the almost 600 pages in two days. Warning: Do not read if you have anything important to do the next day.

  • Was this review helpful?
    3
    0
    Absolutely Flipping Amazing!
    by Tomato Rodriguez
    3 years ago

    You'd be hard to come by a book that has more drama, intrigue, secrets, deceit, complex and compelling family dynamics than THIS BOOK! Without a doubt one of the best books I've ever read. The writing in this book is so beautiful...I have never read another book quite like this. The plot and the way of the writing are so supreme, I MUST own this book and read it MANY times over. RECOMMENDED FOR ANY ONE WHO LIKES TO READ.

  • Was this review helpful?
    1
    0
    Great Book
    by Paul Stevens
    3 years ago

    This is a great story that follows a family in Cape Breton after the father engages in forbidden love. After this he becomes cursed by the father who's daughter he stole away. The book follows the tragic incidents that result in the family's history as a result of this curse. Excellent story a recomended read for anyone

  • Was this review helpful?
    1
    1
    "It kept me glued to my seat"
    by Margaret Stabb
    4 years ago

    An incrediably well written book by Ann-marie McDonald. She kept me glued to my seat with the way she allowed the reader to 'see' what was happening with not just the main character but all of them. It was relatable even though the setting was some time ago. Character development was flawless!

  • Was this review helpful?
    1
    1
    Perfect
    by Justine Marchand
    4 years ago

    I love this book. I have read it more than once, and I love it every time. The characters are interesting, the events are intriguing and exciting, and the imagery is delicious. I could close my eyes and see everything as I'm sure it must have been.

  • Was this review helpful?
    2
    1
    Remarkable
    by Elle V
    4 years ago

    I first came across this novel years ago. But because of Its length I pushed it aside for a "one day" read. I recently made up a must read list of books, and this was on it. I tracked it down at the library, and delved into the world of the Pipers. Enthralling, mysterious, entertaining, shocking, heart breaking, all wrapped up into one amazing book. This book felt so real it could have been a biography. Highly recommend this to anyone, no matter what your reading genre.

  • Was this review helpful?
    2
    1
    Unexpected Greatness
    by Kelsey Murphy
    4 years ago

    After stashing this novel away in a drawer for years I decided to pick it up and give it a shot. After the first chapter I was hooked on this novel and could not put it down for days until I had finished reading it. This novel taught me a lot about the maritimes. I became emotionally connected to all of the characters and yearned to keep unfolding their lives before me in this novel. All in all, it was an amazing novel that I had not expected to be this touching.

  • Was this review helpful?
    2
    0
    Surprising wonderful
    by KE
    4 years ago

    This wasn't a book I would normally have chosen but as it was so highly recommended by a friend, I dove right in and I'm glad I did. Excellent characters and writing, it grabbed me with every page.

  • Was this review helpful?
    1
    1
    Spellbinding
    by Nat Velhuizen
    5 years ago

    I found this story provided a look very realistic and empathetic look at human diversity (sexuality, culture, ethnicity, and life circumstances) as experienced through various character perspectives. I loved how the author has painted such a well developed picture of who the characters are as individuals, and enjoyed the many twists and turns of this families dark history.

  • Was this review helpful?
    0
    2
    Disturbingly intriguing!
    by KJM
    5 years ago

    Someone gave me this book years ago, saying they enjoyed it but not enough to hold on to. Every time I picked up the book and read the back cover, I never found myself in the mood to begin what I considered might be a laborious task. After all, it's not a book full of sunshine and fluff. I ended up giving the book away finally, without having cracked the front cover. About a month ago, I was over at a friend's place, and I found myself perusing her bookshelf. There stood Fall on Your Knees. I picked it up, read the back again, and felt ready to take on the challenge. I borrowed the book and could hardly put it down until I had arrived at the very last word! This book is dark, yet beautifully written. Some of the hardest passages to read content-wise, were the most poetic. This provided a lovely contrast that made persevering through the at-times rough terrain not only manageable, but enjoyable. I sometimes needed to put the book down to digest parts, but it wasn't long before I needed to pick it up again and continue. This book is not for the faint of heart. But if you enjoy meat in your stories, and reality in your characters, then I highly suggest you give this book a chance. It certainly left me with things to mull over once I was done. And I found an abundance of others who had succeeded in conquering this novel with whom to share my thoughts. After all, discussing what you've just read with others is half the fun of reading a great book.

  • Was this review helpful?
    3
    0
    my favourite book EVER!
    by starla~*
    5 years ago

    once you get used to ann-maries's very descrptive writing style, you will be able to appreciate her sheer brilliance! both the plot and character developments in the novel are truly examples of literary genius... as is her astounding use of metaphor. one of the best stories ever told!

  • Was this review helpful?
    3
    0
    Beautifully written
    by Susan DeMont
    5 years ago

    I absolutely loved this book. I found it in among my mother's books, and began reading it because it is set in Nova Scotia, which is where I live and am from. After the first few pages I thought I would not be able to get into it, but it somehow kept me in its grasp. Dealing with some subject matter I normally stay away from, I still give this book 5 stars (or maple leafs). It was so well written and so unique from any other book I have ever read, that I could not put it down from start to finish. Amazing!

1 2 3 4 5 6
  • My Gift List
  • My Wish List
  • Shopping Cart