What would have happened if Great Britain had not joined WWII? Jo
Walton's fascinating alternate histories explore this question from
the viewpoints of a number of characters: a sheltered debutante who
marries a Jewish man, an ambitious policeman with a secret life,
and the daughter of a complicated aristocratic family. Each volume
feels complete unto itself, but taken together, they form a
chilling picture of a history that nearly happened.
Farthing, the first volume, reads like a cozy mystery at first: the
bubbly, cavalier tone of Lucy feels note-perfect as she skates
unaware over the fissures in her family. She doesn't understand the
extent of their support of Hitler and his policies--nor does she
realize how quickly the political becomes personal. The dawning of
her awareness, and her moral growth, forms the counterpoint to the
murder plot that drives the book.
Ha'penny, the second volume, switches narrators, to give us the
tangled political and romantic life of an actress with a family who
might be based on the Mitfords: callous, intelligent, cruel and
full of drama. Viola, far less innocent than Lucy, tightropes
through a series of choices where every option means a betrayal of
something or someone she holds dear.
In the final volume, Half a Crown, Peter Carmichael comes into his
own. He's been the investigator of the crimes in the previous two
books, and now he's risen to the rank of Commander in the Watch:
semi-secret police enforcing political ideology in a Britain grown
increasingly fascist. Carmichael uses his authority to hide a
rescue organization within his own ranks, but even his powers
aren't enough to protect him from blackmail--Carmichael is gay, in
a climate of intolerance, and his enemies don't hesitate to
threaten him with exposure, or worse.
In each book, the stakes rise and the moral dilemmas become more
convoluted. Instead of painting a black-and-white picture of evil
fascism, Walton shows us just how easily such a history could have
happened: good people don't always make good choices, and every one
of us has something to fear. Moreover, situations like these are
happening in the real world around us; the lens of fiction
magnifies and clarifies the issues, so that we can refocus on our
own lives and cultures and see them in a new way. Walton should be
commended for this complex and thought-provoking work.