I am a huge fan of Macguire, but this book disappointed me, too many elements ruined what could have been an amazing story. He seemed confused about what plot he was going to follow. I adored it for the first bit but hated the ending. It was to out of the blue and not following the story he seemed to be presenting in the first half of the novel. If you are looking for great maguire, check out wicked and confessions, that is him at his best.