I really don't think I give kids enough credit. When I started
reading The Lightening Thief by Rick Riordan I was amazed at how
scary it was - and it was labeled as a children's book! Right off
the bat, Percy Jackson, a kid at Yancy Academy vaporizes one of his
teachers and then is told that that teacher never did exist. He
also reiterates a story from Greek mythology about the king titan
Kronos who eats his kids, not believing they are gods - seems scary
to me!
There is violence and subject matter that may not be suitable for
certain ages (family violence, even Greek mythology in general),
but I really enjoyed reading this fast-paced novel. There is humor
mixed throughout (similar to The 6th Grade Nickname Game) and you
can't help but fall in love with the characters.
Fans of the Harry Potter series will love this book. To me, even
though the majority of the main characters are 12-years-old, it
feels almost more grown up than the Harry Potter books. Being a
person who took Greek mythology in university, I appreciated all of
the stories of the Gods and actually checked to see if I still had
my textbook from the class. Reading just the first novel in this
series has peaked my interest in the subject again.
But don't get me wrong - there are definite similarities between
the Percy Jackson and The Olympians series and the Harry Potter
series, but it's all part of the genre. In a book like this for
kids, a boy will have his friends and he has to go somewhere to
hone his talents. This is far from being the spitting image of
Harry Potter and I think with it's references to Greek mythology,
it might interest a few more readers.
After reading so many negative reviews from people saying that Rick
Riordan copied the Harry Potter books, I just have to say that I
knew nothing about these books when I bought them. In fact, if it
wasn't for my husband giving me some money as a bribe for me to
take the dog to the vet, I probably would never have bought them.
As it turns out, I stopped by Wal Mart and had seen this series on
display and thought they might be interesting. I didn't even know
there was a movie made about them.
For the record, I loved the Harry Potter books and I am loving this
series as well. Just take the many books that are out in the
vampire genre nowadays - they all have many similarities but there
are good ones and bad ones. As a reader, you have to be able to
read a book for the sake of not comparing it to another book. Isn't
that what a love of reading is all about?
In fact (and I'm almost done here), I read a passage by Riordan
about the similarities between these two series' of books and he's
really just following the patterns that have been set up for a lot
of books written for children in the past. From that, it's easy to
see how there will always be similarities in children's books -
it's just that the most popular one of the time will be the
comparison book, rather than the first of its genre.
(As a sidenote to books, I'm a musician who plays the piano and
sings - do you know how many times I'm compared to people like Tori
Amos? Or basically any female singer-songwriter who uses a piano?
When, really, it was Kate Bush that pretty much started the whole
thing - NOT Tori. But I digress.)
I highly recommend this series and I can't wait to read more books
written by Riordan!