Published in the USA under the title "A Rule against Murder"
This is an intricate mystery that gives us a new spin in the life
and character of Inspector Gamache. Here we see a more personal
side of him and his relationship with his wife Reine-Marie.
This old fashion story opens at the Manoir Bellechase, an isolated
lodge by Lake Massawippi where the Inspector and Reine-Marie have
enjoyed celebrating their wedding anniversary in the past. This
year, they find themselves sharing this luxurious inn with a highly
dysfunctional wealthy English family, who have come to pay tribute
to their deceased father. Murder is suspected when a member of the
family is found dead, a victim of unusual circumstances. Naturally,
the charming Inspector Gamache gets involved, digging beneath the
family bitterness to solve the devious crime.
Ms Penny is meticulous in her description of this very unpleasant
family, all have secrets to hide and the narrative superbly
captures the resulting emotions and tension. Humour is successfully
added to portray this greedy, selfish family. True to her tradition
she also gives us what we come expect: the usual attention to the
domestic details, such as menu and gardening and other day to day
activities of the Inn.
Although I enjoyed this novel, I admit it is not my favourite. I
found it is slow in action, too centered on the family and a murder
lacking plausibility.