Like a lot of Atlantic Canadian fiction, The Republic of Nothing is
about the life of a family, as well as about an island. In an
anarchist utopia, the family is the island no matter what strangers
find their way over the bridge. While Choyce tackles a lot of
family issues naitive to this genre, he manages to portray Nova
Scotians, Canadians and our relationship with America rather well.
Except of course that we're not all Conservative.
While The Republic of Nothing approaches politics, family life,
sex, romance, in a (mostly) coming of age tale, I did come out with
quite a few critiques. As a writer, I find the first quarter of the
novel to be very cut-and-paste formulaic in each chapter. The first
ten chapters or so start by telling you what happens, and going
back through the incident with more detail. The story became much
more engaging when it stopped, and the plot really started. Ian
McQuade has made strange, unhealthy conclusions about sex equalling
love, and his love interest is almost too picture-perfect except
for her troublesome attachment to the United States. Perhaps I'm
being a little bit critical, but who publishes a review in their
own book that comes from a user on Amazon.com?
For anyone who is wondering what they are as a Nova Scotian, Lesley
Choyce's portrayl is fascinating and hits close to home. If you
live here, you will relate to this tale. For any strangers
wondering about the nature of Atlantic Canada, Choyce is a great
depiction of our modern sense of self...