I really enjoyed this book! Phlip Pullman is one of my favoutite authours. I enjoyed this book alot, all the things that are covered up in Victorian Society are exposed, all the things everyone always pretended weren't there are let out with a horrifying end! Sally make an excellent heroine who uses her many ways to figure out the riddle and learn the secret wich she nearly loses her self and her life whilst going after it. A must read!! just as compelling as " His Dark Materials". Another excellent story of a brave Victorian Girl!