As an adult reader I enjoyed these books. Particularly liked Twilight and Eclipse. Found parts of New Moon and Breaking Dawn slow moving (struggled to get through the beginning of Breaking Dawn). Found the characters quite believable and liked the whole storyline. Found the endings in most cases quite predictable. STRONGLY disagree with the age recommendation that the site gives; would not say that anyhing past the first 2 books is appropriate for this age. The storyline (in particular in Breaking Dawn) is not appropriate for this age group, nor do I think the story would apply to this age range. Would definately say 14+ for the last two. Gave a 4 for books 1,3 but would give 3's for 2,4.