The reviews of this book are generally positive, but I would not
agree that it's a "page-turner".
It follows two young Canadian natives, who fought in WW1. It has
accurate facts; about the Ross Rifles that jammed, the introduction
of the creeping barrage, the futility of trench warfare, and the
realities of trenchfoot. They refer to the Germans as Huns, Boche
or Fritz, which was accurate for WW1. The brutality of war is
portrayed well, as they are involved in many key Canadian battles,
like the Somme, Vimy Ridge, Hill 70, Ypres, Amiens and
Passchendaele.
This book gives the reader a better understanding of natives, their
view of non-natives, the treatment of the natives by "whites", the
horrors of residential schools, and the pagan practices of the
natives, which this author apparently paints in a "noble savage"
light. But the cannibalism, murder and black arts made me have a
hard time liking the characters. He also misunderstands,
misrepresents and mocks Christianity, having only the example of
Catholics at residential schools.
The author's description of how these isolated Indians viewed the
outside world was funny. The first time they saw a car, they
couldn't figure out how it moved, and hypothesized that the man
must be pedalling it.
It is beautifully written. An example was the old woman's
description of her first look at a steam train. "the old ones call
it the iron toboggan...the one bright eye shining in the sunlight
and the iron nose that sniffs the track...the people in front of me
tense, then move closer to the track, not further away as I would
have expected...it whistles like a giant eagle screaming, so close
now I must cover my ears...I watch the beast pull up and give one
last sigh, as if it is very tired from the long journey, smoke
pouring from its sides."
Early on, Xavier, who doesn't speak as much English as Elijah, is
in training to go to war. He would rather sleep under the stars. He
gets Elijah to teach him how to ask, and practices for a day before
he gets it right. Elijah tricks him, and has Xavier go to the
officers and say, "May I be so bold as to request different
sleeping quarters? Perhaps outside away from the atrocious snoring
of my fellow soldiers?" It was not well received. :(
Also, although I admire the skill of snipers, this shows that you
can't kill like that, and not have it affect you, eventually.