This book is one of my favourites ... such an interesting depiction of two worlds (the old/traditional vs modern/city) and the difficulty in reconciling the differences and choosing where you belong. A refreshing read with great characters and a beautiful landscape. One that you don't want to end.

The novel is a follow up to Mr. Boyden’s award winning novel “Three Days Road”, recounting the histories and lives of two fictional James Bay Cree families (The Birds and the Whiskeyjacks). This latest novel centers on Will Bird, son of Xavier Bird, the heroic soldier we were introduced to previously. The story comes to live through two intertwined monologues. We follow Will’s thoughts while he recovers from a serious plane crash, a near death encounter that has left him comatose in a hospital bed. Will is an engaging storyteller, a bush pilot by trade and a charming alcoholic by fate with many tales of adventure to tell, some a hoot and some distressful to hear. Alternate chapters are narrated by his niece Annie Bird while she sits in vigil by his bedside trying to stimulate him back to the living. She uses the time to recount her adventures in Toronto, Montreal and New York while in search of her lost sister Suzanne. These flashbacks create short stories in their lives, each one a glimpse into the desolate forests that surround James Bay and the all too similar affect the underground fashion world can have on someone not accustom to the rat race of the big cities. Each layer reveals secrets of violence, incompetence, kindness, love and compassion. The novel is hard to get into at first, the story launches quickly into two narratives, each one hard to decipher which character is talking and how the bits of information fit together. I gradually immersed myself into the tale and once settle, let the story run its course. I was drawn in by the vivid description of Canada’s vast wilderness and its inhabitants who call it home, the Cree. It was an eye opener realizing the challenges and hardship native people face in big cities where there is a multitude of cultures all trying to survive. The characterization is powerful and the players come across as genuine and loveable. Although the pacing is very slow and the reading is tedious at times, in retrospect I enjoyed the refreshing and informative look into another way of life.

This is a beautiful book, and one of the most delicious parts of it is the Canadian wilderness experience. Boyden has attempted to capture the spirituality of life on Native reservation land, and does an impressive job. I recommend all Canadians read this and learn from it. It is really beyond description in the short time I have to write this review. However, I always lend my favourite books to my sister and she loved it too and gives it five stars. I agree with a few other reviewers in that it is a page turner and unputdownable. I have now purchased Three Day Road and intend to read it very soon.

Would have given this book more stars but the topic was not super interesting to me. This book was well written and did keep my interest.

I hesitated and waffled over reading this book - for no particular reason other than I didn't think it would interest me. Yet there was something about the book that hooked me enough - how many times was it in and out of my shopping bag? I'm soooooo glad that I finally bought it and I took it on my 2 week beach vacation. This is one of the best books I've ever read - 3 Day Road is on my shelf, ready to be read and added to the top 10, make that 11 list! Highly recommend it!

I was not anticipating another well-written book by this author -- it's hard for an author to write two extremely successful books! This book unfolded like a story around the campfire. I was listening intently, waiting for the storyteller (who was taking his time) to tell me his and her story. Boyden's description of the hardships encountered with weather and nature were riveting. I so enjoyed the book as most of my bookclub did too. Can't wait for the final book in the trilogy.

This book is an example of excellence in Canadian literature, and I found it to be well worth the money and my time. I hope it will become part of the curriculum in Canadian literature courses as it raises and develops many important cultural and societal issues in Canadian society. I guess more important than what I think of the book as a white, Anglo Saxon Canadian reader is what a native Canadian living in the north would think of it. I hope it is a fair representation of their lives and issues, their strengths and concerns. I hope the book treats their people with all the respect that they deserve as Canadians .

I am not one to tear apart someone for trying but i have to say this is not an award winner in my opinion. Too underdeveloped to be an award winner. The author does description and narrative well, but the story is too loose. I had no attachment to the characters and the ending seemed contrived. I felt it was just an average read but i feel there are definite streaks of greatness and look forward to future writing by him.

Boyden did a wonderful job on his second novel Through Black Spruce. Similar to his first, Three Day Road, the story alternates between two main characters - Will Bird (Xavier Bird's son) and his neice Annie. This well crafted novel drew me in within the first few pages and it was very hard to put down. I love Boyden's writing style, especially the dialogue between characters - he captures the subtle dialect differences that exist in N. Ontario communities very well. Although it wasn't as great as Three Day Road (in my opinion) this was an excellent novel that had me hooked until the last page. I can't wait for the third book in the trilogy to be released!

The best way to describe this book is that it is fundamentally about people at the crossroads -- between the traditional and the modern, good and evil, young and old. The novel is a slightly complicated read since Boyden uses a double monologue of both his protagonists Will and Annie. Although slightly distracting at first, both narratives intersect together nicely so it isn't all that difficult to follow. Boyden is a great storyteller there is no doubt about that. I would have appreciated slightly more lyricism in his writing though which at times feels a little mechanical -- for such a great story, it lacks that literary touch. The characters are rich and complex and Boyden does a great job to explore their inner feelings. Overall, I highly recommend "Through Black Spruce" -- it is well-deserving of the Giller Prize. I would call it a Canadian classic, but definitely a true gem.