Which Comes First, Cardio Or Weights?: Workout Myths, Training Truths, And Other Surprising Discoveries From The Science Of Exercise by Alex HutchinsonWhich Comes First, Cardio Or Weights?: Workout Myths, Training Truths, And Other Surprising Discoveries From The Science Of Exercise by Alex Hutchinson

Which Comes First, Cardio Or Weights?: Workout Myths, Training Truths, And Other Surprising…

byAlex Hutchinson

Paperback | May 24, 2011

Pricing and Purchase Info


Earn 115 plum® points

Prices and offers may vary in store


In stock online

Ships free on orders over $25

Available in stores


There’s plenty of conventional wisdom on health and fitness – but how much of it is scientifically sound? The truth is: less than you’d think.

In Which Comes First, Cardio or Weights?, physicist and award-winning journalist Alex Hutchinson tackles dozens of commonly held beliefs and looks at just what research science has – and has not – proven to be true:
Should I exercise when I’m sick? · Do I get the same workout from the elliptical machine that I get from running? · What role does my brain play in fatigue? · Will running ruin my knees? · To lose weight, is it better to eat less or exercise more? · How should I adapt my workout routine as I get older? · Does it matter what I’m thinking about when I train? · Will drinking coffee help or hinder my performance? · Should I have sex the night before a competition?
This myth-busting book covers the full spectrum of exercise science and offers the latest in research from around the globe, as well as helpful diagrams and plenty of practical tips on using proven science to improve fitness, reach weight loss goals, and achieve better competition results.

ALEX HUTCHINSON is a contributing editor at Popular Mechanics magazine, senior editor at Canadian Running magazine, and columnist for the Globe and Mail. He represented Canada internationally as a distance runner from 1997 to 2008. He holds a master’s in journalism from Columbia and a Ph.D. in physics from Cambridge, and he did his pos...
Title:Which Comes First, Cardio Or Weights?: Workout Myths, Training Truths, And Other Surprising…Format:PaperbackDimensions:336 pages, 8.45 × 5.51 × 0.9 inPublished:May 24, 2011Publisher:McClelland & StewartLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:0771039816

ISBN - 13:9780771039812

Look for similar items by category:


Rated 5 out of 5 by from Great book for Fitness Geeks & Newbies alike While the 4 Hour Body sells a million copies a day, this gem of a book goes almost unnoticed on the book shelves. And that's too bad The author scours the scientific literature to separate fitness/exercise FACT from MYTH. It's a great read for fitness geeks and newbies alike - not too "sciencey" for fitness newcomers and challenging enough for big fitness geeks like myself.
Date published: 2011-09-28
Rated 5 out of 5 by from An indispensable fitness reference Whether you are just beginning to incorporate exercise into your life or you are a dedicated exercise nut, this book offers answers to the myriad of questions that have likely crossed your mind before, during, and after exercising. You can read the table of contents here: http://www.scribd.com/doc/55912015/Cardio-or-Weights-table-of-contents (Tell me you haven't asked yourself some of those very questions!) Hutchinson has really done his research, pulling together and distilling the latest and best studies into one concise, entertaining volume. The book is essentially a reference that doesn't require cover-to-cover reading, but you'll find yourself doing just that because of Hutchinson's engaging writing style. Well placed anecdotes and humourous observations liven up what potentially could have been pretty dry reading. While a lot of the information is useful in a purely practical way, you might be surprised by how much this book can motivate you to get moving! Not only does the book make a compelling case for the benefits of exercise, it also dispels some of the doubts (or excuses!) that may have been holding you back from either exercising at all or from getting more out of your workouts.
Date published: 2011-06-08

Read from the Book

In 1960, President-Elect John F. Kennedy wrote an article for Sports Illustrated called “The Soft American,” lamenting the declining role of physical activity in everyday life. “Today human activity, the labor of the human body, is rapidly being engineered out of working life,” he wrote. “By the 1970s, according to many economists, the man who works with his hands will be almost extinct.” That prediction didn’t quite pan out—but it’s certainly true that, for most of us, physical activity is now a choice rather than the necessity it was for our ancestors. Kennedy was concerned that Americans wouldn’t have the “vigor and determination” necessary to match the Soviet Union; today, we’ve realized that physical fitness is essential to the health of our bodies and minds. But the basic challenge remains the same: if you’ve just begun working out recently, or you’re about to head to the gym for the first time, you need to know what to expect. How hard to push, how long it will take to see results, how to make the most of your workout time, how to minimize the risks associated with starting an exercise program—these are the issues you should consider before getting started. How long does it take to get in shape?First, the good news. Your body actually starts getting stronger and healthier just hours after you start working out. But if you’re wondering how long it will take to rock a six-pack—well, you’ll have to be a bit more patient. A few years ago, exercise scientist Megan Anderson and her colleagues at the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse put 25 sedentary volunteers through an intense six-week exercise program modeled on the bold claims made by companies such as Bowflex and Body-for-Life. Despite sticking to the program religiously, zero percent of the subjects developed instant washboard abs. In fact, a panel of six judges could detect no differences whatsoever in their physical attractiveness before and after the program. That doesn’t mean nothing was happening. After just a few strength training sessions, your brain learns to recruit more muscle fibers and make them contract all at once to produce a greater force. This “neural activation” kicks in after only a few workouts, allowing you to get stronger almost immediately, well before your muscles get noticeably bigger. Further strength gains come as the individual muscle fibers within your muscles get bigger, which starts in as little as two weeks if you’re training intensely. But it takes longer for these changes to be noticeable: even with sophisticated lab equipment, researchers can’t usually detect changes in fat and muscle composition until after about nine weeks of training. Similarly, a University of Tokyo study published in 2010 saw the biggest increases in strength after two months and the biggest boost in muscle size after three months. To achieve these rapid gains, the subjects were doing four very hard workouts a week. For the average person at the gym, it will take six months or more to see significant sculpting of the body even though strength has been increasing from day one. Weight loss is more difficult to predict, because it depends on your starting point, your health history, your genetics, and your diet as well as your workout routine. But like strength training, aerobic exercise produces major health and performance benefits long before you see them in the mirror. Aerobic exercise increases the number of mitochondria, which are essentially the “cellular power plants” in your muscles that use oxygen to produce energy: the more mitochondria you have, the farther and faster you can run, and the more fat your muscles will burn. Studies have found that about six weeks of training will boost mitochondria levels by 50 to 100 percent. Health benefits, on the other hand, kick in after a single bout of aerobic exercise. For about 48 hours after a workout, your muscles will be consuming more glucose than usual, helping to bring down blood-sugar levels. After a few workouts, your insulin sensitivity will begin to improve, offering further control of blood sugar. The bottom line: “Getting in shape” is a journey that extends over months and even years, but the process—and the benefits— start as soon as you begin exercising. So if you’re having trouble staying motivated without immediate physical changes, track your strength and endurance gains along the way. Am I exercising enough?This is a hugely controversial question, but not in the way you might expect. Almost all experts agree about what the science says—but they’re bitterly divided about what message they should convey to the public. Decades of research have made two things crystal clear:1. Every bit of exercise helps, even in scraps as short as 10 minutes.2. More is almost always better. The challenge is conveying the second message without discouraging the people who are still struggling with the first. And there are a lot of people struggling: in 2008, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that a quarter of Americans hadn’t done any physical activity at all in the previous month. And less than half met the modest government mandated Healthy People 2010 goal of 30 minutes of moderate exercise five times a week. In Canada, only a third of people are meeting a similar goal of 30 minutes at a moderate effort, four times a week. From a public health perspective, the top priority is getting those inactive people to start moving, even a little bit. Going from zero to slightly active offers the biggest possible health boost, according to a recent National Institutes of Health study that followed 250,000 men and women between the ages of 50 and 71. Those who were just slightly active but didn’t manage to meet the exercise guidelines were 30 percent less likely to die than those who were totally inactive. Stepping it up to moderate exercise reduced risk by only eight more percent, and adding in some vigorous exercise subtracted an additional 12 percent. When you combine that data, you find that getting half an hour of moderate to vigorous exercise five times a week cuts your risk of dying from all causes in half. So far, so good. The controversy starts when you ask what happens if you do more exercise than the government guidelines recommend. According to researchers like Paul Williams of the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, you keep piling up more and more benefits. Williams has been following a cohort of 120,000 runners since 1991, tracking how much they run and what happens to their health. With this enormous sample size, his National Runners’ Health Study has been able to uncover a pronounced “dose–response” relationship between aerobic exercise and health: the more you do, and the harder you do it, the more benefits you get. What kind of benefits, you ask? Well, in a series of studies stretching back over a decade, Williams has found that the risk of everything from big killers like diabetes, stroke, and heart attack to less common conditions like glaucoma, cataracts, and macular degeneration can be reduced by as much as 70 percent by going beyond the standard exercise guidelines. In every case, the benefits relate to both how much running the subjects do and how fast they do it. For example, every additional mile in your average daily run lowers your glaucoma risk by 8 percent. And speeding up your 10K time by one meter per second (the difference between, say, finishing times of 53 minutes and 40 minutes) lowers heart attack risk by about 50 percent. It is true that overdoing your workout regimen can weaken your immune system (see p. 23), especially if you’re not eating and sleeping well. And elite athletes training for hours a day at extremely high intensities sometime suffer from “overtraining” syndrome. But the message of Williams’s research is that the risks of doing too much—and these results apply to all forms of aerobic exercise, not just running—pale in comparison to the benefits of doing a bit more. Which should I do first: cardio or weights?Let’s start with one incontrovertible fact: you can’t fulfill your ultimate potential as both a weightlifter and a marathoner at the same time. Too many hours sweating on the elliptical will hinder your ability to put on muscle, and pumping too much iron will slow your endurance gains. But most of us don’t want Olympic medals in both events. We just want some combination of reasonable cardiovascular fitness and non-vanishing muscles—a desire shared by many elite athletes. Top basketball players, for instance, need strength and explosiveness but also have to last for a full 40 to 60 minutes on the court. The solution, according to Derek Hansen, the head coach for strength and conditioning at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, British Columbia, and a speed consultant to numerous Olympic athletes, is to mix it up. For basketball players, he says, “we typically have our athletes lift weights, jump, and sprint one day, then do their aerobic work the next day.” When Hansen’s court-sport athletes are combining weight training with cardio in a single session, the weights come first, since building power is their first priority. This approach—starting with whichever activity is most important to you—is widely used by elite athletes. Until recently, scientists thought it was simply a matter of logistics: if you’re tired from the treadmill, you can’t lift as much weight, so over time you put on less muscle. But new techniques now allow researchers to directly measure which specific proteins are produced in muscles after different types of exercises. It turns out that the sequence of cellular events that leads to bigger muscles is determined in part by the same “master switch”—an enzyme called amp kinase— that controls adaptations for better endurance. But you can’t have it both ways: the switch is set either to “bigger muscles” or to “better endurance,” and the body can’t instantly change from one setting to the other. How you start your workout determines which way the switch will be set for the session. So if your goal is beach muscles, your weights routine should come first. If you’re preparing for an upcoming 5K race, do your full cardio workout before tacking on weights at the end. And if you’re looking for the best of both worlds, Hansen suggests mixing it up, both within a single session and from day to day: “The variability will be good, as it challenges your body and metabolism.” Can I get fit in seven minutes a week?Breathless claims about exercise regimens that produce near instant results with minimal effort are generally the domain of late-night infomercials. So it might seem surprising that one of the hot topics at the American College of Sports Medicine’s annual meeting over the last few years has been research into “high-intensity interval training” (hit), whose proponents suggest that many of the benefits of traditional endurance training can be achieved with a few short bouts of intense exercise totaling as little as seven minutes a week. Exercise physiologist Martin Gibala and his colleagues at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, have performed a remarkable series of studies in which their subjects cycle as hard as they can for 30 seconds, then rest for four minutes, and repeat four to six times. They do this short workout three times a week. “The gains are quite substantial,” Gibala says. Compared to control subjects who cycle continuously for up to an hour a day, five times a week, the hit subjects show similar gains in exercise capacity, muscle metabolism, and cardiovascular fitness. In fact, the group’s latest study shows that hit improves the structure and function of key arteries that deliver blood to the muscles and heart—just like typical cardio training. Similar studies by University of Guelph researcher Jason Talanian have found that high-intensity interval training also increases the body’s ability to burn fat, an effect that persists even during lower-intensity activities following the interval training. The results are no surprise to elite cyclists, runners, and swimmers, who have relied on interval training for decades to achieve peak performance. To break the four-minute mile in 1954, Roger Bannister famously relied on interval sessions of ten 60-second sprints separated by two minutes of rest, because his duties as a medical student on clinical rotation limited his training time to half an hour a day at lunch. Such time constraints are the main reason Gibala advocates hit, since studies consistently find that lack of time is the top reason that people don’t manage to get the 30 minutes of daily exercise recommended by public health guidelines. “We’re not saying that it’s a panacea that has all the benefits of endurance training,” he says. “But it’s a way that people can get away with less.” More recent studies have started to piece together exactly how hit sessions work. A study at the University of Western Ontario compared volunteers who ran four to six 30-second sprints with four minutes’ rest (just like Gibala’s hit workout for cycling) with another group running steadily for 30 to 60 minutes at a time. After six weeks of training three times a week, both groups made identical gains in endurance and lost similar amounts of fat. In the “long runs” group, the endurance gains came from increases in the amount of blood pumped by the heart; in the hit group, almost all the gains came from the muscles themselves, which improved their ability to extract oxygen from circulating blood. Since it’s important to have a healthy heart and healthy muscles, this suggests you shouldn’t rely exclusively on hit workouts. As with cardio and weights, a mixture is best. High-intensity exercise is generally thought to carry some risks, so sedentary or older people should check with a doctor before trying hit. Interestingly, though, University of British Columbia researcher Darren Warburton has studied hit training in cancer and heart disease patients and found that these higher-risk populations can also benefit safely from hit. There is one catch—the disclaimer at the end of the infomercial, if you will. To cram the benefits of an hour-long workout into a few short minutes, you also have to compress the effort you would have spent. “That’s the trade-off,” Gibala says. “Going all out is uncomfortable. It hurts.” But at least with this approach, it’s over quickly.

Table of Contents

Introduction: What This Book Is (and Isn’t)

1: Getting Started
How long does it take to get in shape?
Am I exercising enough?
Which should I do first: cardio or weights?
Can I get fit in seven minutes a week?
Can exercise increase my risk of a heart attack?
Will exercising in cold air freeze my lungs?
When is it too hot to exercise?
Should I avoid exercising outside when air pollution is high?
How will exercise affect my immune system?
Is motivation to exercise genetic?
How long does it take to get unfit?

2: Fitness Gear
Is running on a treadmill better or worse than running outside?
Is the elliptical machine just as good as running?
Do I really need specialized shoes for walking, running, tennis, basketball, and so on?
Will running barefoot help me avoid injuries?
Will compression clothing help me exercise?
Does walking with poles give me a better workout?
Are sports video games real workouts?
What should I do with wobble boards and exercise balls?
Can a mouthpiece make me stronger, faster, and moreflexible?
Is there any benefit to strengthening my breathing muscles?

3: The Physiology of Exercise
What role does my brain play in fatigue?
Does lactic acid cause muscle fatigue?
Why do I get sore a day or two after hard exercise?
What is “VO2max” and should I have mine tested?
What is “lactate threshold” and should I have mine tested?
How can I avoid muscle cramps?
What’s happening when I get a stitch?
At what time of day am I strongest and fastest?

4: Aerobic Exercise
Why should I do cardio if I just want to build my muscles?
How hard should my cardio workout feel?
How do I determine my maximum heart rate?
What’s the best way to breathe during exercise?
Will running on hard surfaces increase my risk of injuries?
Do I run “wrong”?
What’s the best way to run up and down hills?
Does pumping my arms make me run faster?
Do spinning classes offer any benefits that I can’t get from biking on my own?
Will taking the stairs make a real difference to my health? 96

5: Strength and Power
Do I need strength training if I just want to be lean and fit?
How much weight should I lift, and how many times?
How do I tone my muscles without bulking up?
What’s the difference between strength and power?
Free weights or machines: what’s the difference, and which should I use?
Can body-weight exercises like push-ups and sit-ups be as effective as lifting weights?
Can lifting weights fix my lower-back pain?
Will I get a better workout if I hire a personal trainer?
Do I need extra protein to build muscle?

6: Flexibility and Core Strength
Will stretching help me avoid injuries?
Could stretching before exercise make me slower and weaker?
Do flexible runners run more efficiently?
How should I warm up before exercise?
Will stretching after exercise help me avoid next-days soreness?
Where is my “core,” and do I need to strengthen it?
What are the benefits of yoga for physical fitness?
What are the benefits of yoga for overall wellness?

7: Injuries and Recovery
Ouch, I think I sprained something. How long should I stay off it?
Will a post-exercise ice bath help me recover more quickly?
Will a heat pack or hot bath soothe my aching body?
Will massage help me avoid soreness and recover more quickly from workouts?
Should I take painkillers for post-workout soreness?
How long does it take to recover after a marathon or other long, intense effort?
Can “platelet-rich plasma” cure my tennis elbow or Achilles tendon?
How can I reduce my risk of stress fractures?
Should I exercise when I’m sick?
Will having a few drinks affect my workout the next day?

8: Exercise and Aging
What’s the cumulative effect of all the exercise I’ve done over the years?
Will running ruin my knees?
How should I adapt my workout routine as I get older?
How quickly will my performance decline as I age?
How can I stay motivated to exercise as my performances decline?
What are the pros and cons of exercising in water?
What type of exercise is best for maintaining strong bones?
Can exercise keep my dna from aging?

9: Weight Management
Is it possible to be fat and healthy at the same time?
Is weight loss simply the difference between “calories in” and “calories out?”
To lose weight, is it better to eat less or exercise more?
How can I take advantage of the “fat-burning” zone?
Won’t exercise make me eat more and gain weight?
Can I lose weight while gaining (or maintaining) muscle?
Is lifting weights better than cardio for weight loss?
Will I burn more calories commuting by bike or on foot?
Can I control hunger by manipulating my appetite hormones?
Will sitting too long at work counteract all my fitness gains?

10: Nutrition and Hydration
Should I carbo-load by eating pasta the night before a competition?
What should I eat to avoid stomach problems during exercise?
What should I eat and drink to refuel after working out? 
How much should I drink to avoid dehydration during exercise?
Is it possible to hydrate too much?
What ingredients do I really need in a sports drink?
Will taking antioxidant vitamins block the health benefits of exercise?
Should I be taking probiotics?
Will vitamin D make me a better athlete?
Is there any benefit to deliberately training with low energy stores?
Can I get the nutrients I need for a heavy exercise regimen from a vegetarian or vegan diet?

11: Mind and Body
If my brain is tired, will my body’s performance suffer?
Does it matter what I’m thinking about when I train?
Does listening to music or watching tv help or hurt my workout?
Will I perform better under pressure if I focus harder?
Can swearing help me push harder in a workout?
Is there such a thing as “runner’s high”?
Will taking a fitness class or joining a team change my brain chemistry during workouts?
What are the effects of exercise on the brain?

12: The Competitive Edge
How should I adjust my training in the final days before a competition?
Should I have sex the night before a competition?
Can drinking slushies boost my performance on hot days?
Will drinking coffee help or hinder my performance?
Does competing in front of a crowd improve performance?
How much sleep do I need for optimal physical performance?
How should I pace myself in a long-distance race?
Is endurance or sprint speed more important in field sports like soccer?

Conclusions: From Lab to Gym

Editorial Reviews

“Authoritative and easy to use…. This book answers all the big questions.”
— Amby Burfoot, Editor at Large, Runner’s World magazine
“Factual, informative and empowering.”
Kirkus Reviews