Accountability for Killing: Moral Responsibility for Collateral Damage in Americas Post-9/11 Wars

Hardcover | December 10, 2013

byNeta Crawford

not yet rated|write a review
In May 2009, American B-1B bombers dropped 2,000-pound and 500-pound bombs in the village of Garani, Afghanistan following a Taliban attack. The dead included anywhere from twenty five to over one hundred civilians. The U.S. military went into damage control mode, making numerous apologies tothe Afghan government and the townspeople. Afterward, the military announced that it would modify its aerial support tactics. This episode was hardly an anomaly. As anyone who has followed the Afghanistan war knows, these types of incidents occur with depressing regularity. Indeed, as Neta Crawfordshows in Accountability for Killing, they are intrinsic to the American way of warfare today. While the military has prioritized reducing civilian casualties, it has not come close to eliminating them despite significant progress in recent years, for a very simple reason: American reliance on airpower and, increasingly, drone technology, which is intended to reduce American casualties. Yetthe long distance from targets, the power of the explosives, and the frequency of attacks necessarily produces civilian casualties over the course of a long war. Working from these basic facts, Crawford offers a sophisticated and intellectually powerful analysis of culpability and moral responsibility in war. The dominant paradigm of legal and moral responsibility in war today stresses both intention and individual accountability. Deliberate killing ofcivilians is outlawed and international law blames individual soldiers and commanders for such killing. But also under international law, civilian killing may be forgiven if it was unintended and incidental to a militarily necessary operation. Given the nature of contemporary war, though, Crawfordcontends that this argument is no longer satisfactory. As she demonstrates, "unintended" deaths of civilians are too often dismissed as unavoidable, inevitable, and accidental. Yet essentially, the very law that protects noncombatants from deliberate killing allows unintended killing. An individualsoldier may be sentenced life in prison or death for deliberately killing even a small number of civilians, but the large scale killing of dozens or even hundreds of civilians may be forgiven if it was unintentional - "incidental" to a military operation. She focuses on the causes of these many episodes of foreseeable collateral damage and the moral responsibility for them. Why was there so much unintended killing of civilians in the U.S. wars zones in Afghanistan, Iraq and Pakistan? Is "collateral damage" simply an unavoidable consequence of allwars? Why, when the U.S. military tries so hard to limit collateral damage, does so much of it seem to occur? Trenchant, original, and ranging across security studies, international law, ethics, and international relations, Accountability for Killing will reshape our understanding of the ethics ofcontemporary war.

Pricing and Purchase Info

$43.95

Ships within 1-3 weeks
Ships free on orders over $25

From the Publisher

In May 2009, American B-1B bombers dropped 2,000-pound and 500-pound bombs in the village of Garani, Afghanistan following a Taliban attack. The dead included anywhere from twenty five to over one hundred civilians. The U.S. military went into damage control mode, making numerous apologies tothe Afghan government and the townspeople. A...

Neta Crawford is Professor of Political Science and African American Studies at Boston University, and author of Argument and Change in World Politics (Cambridge, 2002; winner of the 2003 Robert Jervis and Paul Schroeder Best Book Award, International History and Politics section of the APSA).

other books by Neta Crawford

Argument and Change in World Politics
Argument and Change in World Politics

Kobo ebook|Jul 1 1998

$46.49 online$60.37list price(save 22%)
Format:HardcoverDimensions:496 pages, 9.25 × 6.12 × 0.98 inPublished:December 10, 2013Publisher:Oxford University PressLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:0199981728

ISBN - 13:9780199981724

Look for similar items by category:

Customer Reviews of Accountability for Killing: Moral Responsibility for Collateral Damage in Americas Post-9/11 Wars

Reviews

Extra Content

Table of Contents

Introduction1. Grammar and Vocabulary2. How They Die3. Norms in Tension4. When Soldiers Snap5. Command Responsibility6. Organizational Responsibility7. Political Responsibility8. Public Responsibility9. Conclusion