Disrupted Dialogue: Medical Ethics and the Collapse of Physician-Humanist Communication (1770-1980) by Robert M. VeatchDisrupted Dialogue: Medical Ethics and the Collapse of Physician-Humanist Communication (1770-1980) by Robert M. Veatch

Disrupted Dialogue: Medical Ethics and the Collapse of Physician-Humanist Communication (1770-1980)

byRobert M. Veatch

Hardcover | September 22, 2004

Pricing and Purchase Info


Earn 424 plum® points

Prices and offers may vary in store


In stock online

Ships free on orders over $25

Not available in stores


Medical ethics changed dramatically in the past 30 years because physicians and humanists actively engaged each other in discussions that sometimes led to confrontation and controversy, but usually have improved the quality of medical decision-making. Before then medical ethics had beenisolated for almost two centuries from the larger philosophical, social, and religious controversies of the time. There was, however, an earlier period where leaders in medicine and in the humanities worked closely together and both fields were richer for it. This volume begins with the 18thcentury Scottish Enlightenment when professors of medicine such as John Gregory, Edward Percival, and the American, Benjamin Rush, were close friends of philosophers like David Hume, Adam Smith, and Thomas Reid. They continually exchanged views on matters of ethics with each other in print, atmeetings of elite intellectual groups, and at the dinner table. Then something happened, physicians and humanists quit talking with each other. In searching for the causes of the collapse, this book identifies shifts in the social class of physicians, developments in medical science, and changesin the patterns of medical education. Only in the past three decades has the dialogue resumed as physicians turned to humanists for help just when humanists wanted their work to be relevant to real-life social problems. Again, the book asks why, finding answers in the shift from acute to chronicdisease as the dominant pattern of illness, the social rights revolution of the 1960's, and the increasing dissonance between physician ethics and ethics outside medicine. The book tells the critical story of how the breakdown in communication between physicians and humanists occurred and how itwas repaired when new developments in medicine together with a social revolution forced the leaders of these two fields to resume their dialogue.
Robert M. Veatch is at Georgetown University.
Title:Disrupted Dialogue: Medical Ethics and the Collapse of Physician-Humanist Communication (1770-1980)Format:HardcoverDimensions:344 pages, 6.3 × 9.21 × 0.91 inPublished:September 22, 2004Publisher:Oxford University PressLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:019516976X

ISBN - 13:9780195169768

Look for similar items by category:


Table of Contents

Part I. Scotland2. The Beginnings of Medicine as an Isolated SciencePart II. England3. Eighteenth Century England's Integration of Medicine and the Humanities4. The Isolation of the English PhysicianPart III. The Movement of Medical Ethics from Britain to the U.S. and Elsewhere in the English Speaking World5. The Physician-Humanist Interaction in the Eighteenth Century in the U.S.6. The Scientizing of Medicine in the U.S.7. Some Physicians Who Almost Confront the Humanities8. Diverging Traditions: Professional and Religious Medical Ethics of the Nineteenth Century9. Medical Ethics in New Zealand and Nova Scotia: Test Cases10. The End of the Isolation: Hints of Reconvergence11. The New Enlightenment: The 1970'sAfterword: The 1980s and Beyond

Editorial Reviews

"Disrupted Dialogue offers an intriguing new perspective on isolation and innovation in the history of Anglo-Americal medical ethics. It also presents a wealth of valuable new biographical and bibliographic information on the major and minor figures that shaped this history. It deserves acareful reading by anyone seriously interested in the history of modern medical ethics."--Bulletin of the History of Medicine