Excusing Crime by Jeremy HorderExcusing Crime by Jeremy Horder

Excusing Crime

byJeremy Horder

Hardcover | September 14, 2004

Pricing and Purchase Info


Earn 1,095 plum® points

Prices and offers may vary in store


In stock online

Ships free on orders over $25

Not available in stores


When should someone who may have intentionally or knowingly committed criminal wrongdoing be excused? Excusing Crime examines what excusing conditions are, and why familiar excuses, such as duress, are thought to fulfil those conditions. The 'classical' view of excuses sees them as rational defects (such as mistake) in the motive force behind an action, but contrasts them with 'denials of responsibility', such as insanity, where the rational defect in that motive force is attributable to a mental defect in the agent him- or herself.This classical view of excuses has a long heritage, and is enshrined in different forms in many of the world's criminal codes, both liberal and non-liberal; however, in this book, Jeremy Horder contends that it is now time to move beyond it.Horder develops a 'liberal' account of excuses, arguing that the 'classical' distinction between rational defects and 'denials of responsibility' is too sharp, and also that the classical view of excuses is too narrow. He contends that it can be right to treat claims as excusatory even if they relyon a combination of elements of rational defect in the motive force behind the action, even if that defect is in part attributable to a mental deficiency in the agent him or herself ('diminished capacity'). Further, he argues that there can be a sound case for excuse even when people can give fullrational assent to their actions, such as when they could not reasonably have been expected to do more than what they did to avoid committing wrongdoing ('due diligence'), or, more rarely, when their conscience understandably left them with no moral freedom to do other than commit the wrong('demands-of-conscience').
Jeremy Horder is Law Commissioner for England and Wales; and Professor of Criminal Law, Porjes Trust Fellow, Worcester College, University of Oxford
Title:Excusing CrimeFormat:HardcoverDimensions:316 pages, 9.21 × 6.14 × 0.91 inPublished:September 14, 2004Publisher:Oxford University PressLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:0198264828

ISBN - 13:9780198264828

Look for similar items by category:


Table of Contents

Table of casesIntroduction1. The domain of excuses: A theoretical overview2. An anatomy of excuses3. Which theory of excuses?4. Liberalism, partial excuses, and short-comers5. Liberalism and the demands-of-conscience excuse6. Excusing strict liability crime: a liberal account beyond the common law agendaBibliographyIndex of authorsGeneral Index

Editorial Reviews

`The rewards for engaging with Horder are well worth the effort, enabling the reader to come to terms with the theoretical bases, and the social and political influences affecting the recognition and development of criminal excuses.'Stanley Yeo, Criminal Law Journal