Godard Between Identity and Difference by John E. DrabinskiGodard Between Identity and Difference by John E. Drabinski

Godard Between Identity and Difference

byJohn E. Drabinski

Paperback | January 5, 2012

Pricing and Purchase Info

$50.65 online 
$55.90 list price save 9%
Earn 253 plum® points

Prices and offers may vary in store


In stock online

Ships free on orders over $25

Not available in stores


This book reads a series of Godard films as interventions in contemporary debate about the language of difference. Godard has something he wants both to preserve (singularity) and destroy (visual and aural totalitarianism). How is it possible to speak about the Other? How is it possible for the Other to speak? Does all speaking about or by the Other render that speaking common, thereby rendering what is different identical? These questions gather together a number of issues that cross and intersect disciplinary boundaries: signification, representation, ethics, politics, and so on.
The problematics with which Drabinski is concerned begin in the debate between Levinas and Derrida, then later in dialogue with Blanchot and Irigaray. To this extent, Godard is particularly well-suited as an interlocutor. Godard's work, especially in the 1970s, is itself a self-conscious form of philosophy. His films theorize themselves, produce a reflexive sound-image language, and so in many ways match the very essence of philosophy: thought thinking thought.

Still, the medium of sound and image complicates any rendering of Godard's work as philosophy. Godard produces a philosophically significant cinematic language, rather than simply narrating or representing philosophical ideas in the medium of film. And this language must be taken seriously in the context of the problem of difference. For, if difference is concerned with signification as such, then the visual and aural retain equal rights with writing (and all questions obtaining therein). Indeed, if part of the problem of speaking about or by the Other is how such speaking traffics in inscription, then cinematic language is certainly an important - and authentically complex - intervention in that problem.

The nature of the debate in this project - how the language of alterity is possible or impossible - immediately breaks disciplinary borders between philosophy, literary theory, film studies, and cultural studies. What it means to engage with film in this context, however, is complicated. To wit, there are two standard treatments of film in philosophy. Film is typically either an example of a philosophical position or philosophy is used to interpret motifs, characters, plot lines, etc. In neither case is film engaged as a form of philosophizing itself, that is, as a language engaged with philosophical problematics.

It is articulating exactly this engagement that this book takes as its primary task. The aim of the project is to read Godard's work as primary texts, with all the attention due the idiosyncratic language of those texts. Framed by the debate about difference and signification, these primary texts register and resonate as transformative interventions. The overarching argument of the book is that Godard's conception and practice of cinematic language opens new, important possibilities for thinking about radical alterity.

John E. Drabinski teaches at Hampshire College. He is the author of Sensibility and Singularity: The Problem of Phenomenology in Levinas.
Title:Godard Between Identity and DifferenceFormat:PaperbackDimensions:176 pages, 9 × 6 × 0.37 inPublished:January 5, 2012Publisher:BloomsburyLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:144111484X

ISBN - 13:9781441114846

Look for similar items by category:


Table of Contents

1. About the Other
2. Separation and Death: Location in Ici et ailleurs
3. The Fate of the Image in Comment ca va?
4. The Unassimilable Body of Numero Deux
5. Spectator, Montage, and Violence

Editorial Reviews

"Drabinski (black studies, Amherst College) has set himself a stiff task in this book: to discuss Godard's films as philosophy. The films, he avers, are not about philosophy but rather are Godard's attempt to enter into a philosophical discourse about the other, the gaze, violence, and responsibility in the contemporary world. In this endeavor, Godard follows the thinking of Emmanuel Levinas and Jacques Derrida...Drabinski does an admirable job of elucidating the difficult intellectual positions and is convincing in his assertion that film (and film criticism) can be philosophy. Summing Up: Recommended. Upper-division undergraduates through faculty." -W. A. Vincent, CHOICE, February 2009