How Aristotle gets by in Metaphysics Zeta by Frank A. LewisHow Aristotle gets by in Metaphysics Zeta by Frank A. Lewis

How Aristotle gets by in Metaphysics Zeta

byFrank A. Lewis

Hardcover | July 6, 2013

Pricing and Purchase Info

$100.13 online 
$134.50 list price save 25%
Earn 501 plum® points

Prices and offers may vary in store


Ships within 1-3 weeks

Ships free on orders over $25

Not available in stores


Frank A. Lewis presents a closely argued exposition of Metaphysics Zeta- - one of Aristotle's most dense and controversial texts. It is commonly understood to contain Aristotle's deepest thoughts on the definition of substance and surrounding metaphysical issues. But people have increasinglycome to recognize how little Aristotle says in Zeta about his own theory of (Aristotelian) form and matter. Instead, he spends the bulk of the book examining "received opinions", often as filtered through his own Organon, but including above all the views of Plato, who is at times friend, and attimes foe. For much of the time, we are left to reconstruct Aristotle's finished views, subject to the constraint that they survive the critique he directs in Zeta at the philosophical tradition.In this book, Lewis argues that in giving his actual conclusion to Zeta in its final chapter, 17, Aristotle drops his earlier, largely critical engagement with received views, and turns approvingly to his own Posterior Analytics. The result is a causal view of (primary) substance, representing theproperty of being a (primary) substance (or the substance of a thing) as, in modern dress, the second-order functional property of (Aristotelian) forms, that they be the cause of being for different compound material substances. The property of being the cause of being for a thing is a roleproperty, and it is realized in different forms and the sets of causal powers associated with them, matching the variety of things that have a form as their substance.Meanwhile, the failure of previous attempts at definition in earlier chapters leaves Aristotle's own definition standing as the "best explanation" for the views proprietary to the theory of form and matter. The point that (Aristotelian) forms are the primary substances is not the main conclusion toZeta, but rather a result his definition must give, if the definition is to be acceptable.
Frank A. Lewis was educated at Cambridge University and Princeton University, and is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Southern California. He taught previously at the University of Arizona and at UCLA; he has held visiting positions at Stanford and at UCLA, and has twice held fellowships from the American Council of Learne...
Title:How Aristotle gets by in Metaphysics ZetaFormat:HardcoverDimensions:336 pagesPublished:July 6, 2013Publisher:Oxford University PressLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:0199664013

ISBN - 13:9780199664016


Table of Contents

IntroductionPart One: The Shape of Zeta1. The Hitchhiker's Guide to Metaphysics ZetaPart Two: Substance as Subject2. Subjects in Metaphysics Zeta 3Part Three: Substance as Essence3. A Start on Essence in Metaphysics Zeta 4Appendix to Chapter 3. Greek Hoper and the Pseudo-Cleft Constructions in English4. Sameness, Substitution, and Essence (I). Metaphysics Z5, the SE, and "A Nose by Any Other Name"Afterword: Reservations and Retractions5. Sameness, Substitution, and Essence (II). The SE, and the Pale Man Argument From Metaphysics Z66. Plato as Friend: Is There Room for Plato in an Aristotelian Theory of Essence?7. Substance as Essence: The Shift to "Partisan" Mode in Zeta 10 and 11Part Four: Substance as Universal8. Substance and Universals (I). Plato as Foe: Setting the Stage in Zeta 13Appendix to Chapter Eight. Mutual Exclusivity and Some Versions of Compatibility9. Substance and Universals (II). Plato on Genus, Species, and Differentia10. Substance and Universals (III). Zeta 15 and 16, and Plato's Fundamental MistakeAppendix to Chapter Ten. Definition, Substance, and Universals: A Puzzle, and Some Speculative ConclusionsPart Five: Back to the Definition of Substance: The End Game11. The Posterior Analytics, and a Fresh Approach to Defining Substance12. Aristotle on the Positive Contributions of ZetaBibiliographyIndex