Minimal Semantics by Emma BorgMinimal Semantics by Emma Borg

Minimal Semantics

byEmma Borg

Hardcover | December 31, 2005

Pricing and Purchase Info

$167.68 online 
$258.00 list price save 35%
Earn 838 plum® points

Prices and offers may vary in store


In stock online

Ships free on orders over $25

Not available in stores


Minimal Semantics asks what a theory of literal linguistic meaning is for - if you were to be given a working theory of meaning for a language right now, what would you be able to do with it? Emma Borg sets out to defend a formal approach to semantic theorising from a relatively new type ofopponent - advocates of what she call 'dual pragmatics'. According to dual pragmatists, rich pragmatic processes play two distinct roles in linguistic comprehension: as well as operating in a post-semantic capacity to determine the implicatures of an utterance, they also operate prior to thedetermination of truth-conditional content for a sentence. That is to say, they have an integral role to play within what is usually thought of as the semantic realm. Borg believes dual pragmatic accounts constitute the strongest contemporary challenge to standard formal approaches to semantics since they challenge the formal theorist to show not merely that there is some role for formal processes on route to determination of semantic content, but that suchprocesses are sufficient for determining content. Minimal Semantics provides a detailed examination of this school of thought, introducing readers who are unfamiliar with the topic to key ideas like relevance theory and contextualism, and looking in detail at where these accounts diverge from theformal approach.Borg's defence of formal semantics has two main parts: first, she argues that the formal approach is most naturally compatible with an important and well-grounded psychological theory, namely the Fodorian modular picture of the mind. Then she argues that the main arguments adduced by dualpragmatists against formal semantics - concerning apparent contextual intrusions into semantic content - can in fact be countered by a formal theory. The defence holds, however, only if we are sensitive to the proper conditions of success for a semantic theory. Specifically, we should reject a rangeof onerous constraints on semantic theorizing (e.g., that it answer epistemic or metaphysical questions, or that it explain our communicative skills) and instead adopt a quite minimal picture of semantics.
Emma Borg is in the Department of Philosophy, University of Reading.
Title:Minimal SemanticsFormat:HardcoverDimensions:298 pages, 9.21 × 6.14 × 0.89 inPublished:December 31, 2005Publisher:Oxford University PressLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:0199270252

ISBN - 13:9780199270255

Look for similar items by category:


Table of Contents

1. A tale of two theories2. Modularity3. Overt context-sensitivity: the problems of indexicality4. Covert context-sensitivity: the problems of underdetermination, inappropriateness, and indeterminacy5. Minimal semantics and the global art of communication

Editorial Reviews

Review by Professor Gerhard Preyer, Buchbesprechungen 25/09/07