Is That Wise, Pig? by Jan ThomasIs That Wise, Pig? by Jan Thomas

Is That Wise, Pig?

byJan ThomasIllustratorJan Thomas

Paper over Board | September 13, 2016

Pricing and Purchase Info

$18.29 online 
$21.99 list price save 16%
Earn 91 plum® points

Prices and offers may vary in store


In stock online

Ships free on orders over $25

Available in stores


Cow and Pig are helping Mouse make a delicious soup, but Pig keeps trying to add ingredients that don’t make sense!

Mouse is making a yummy pot of soup and Cow and Pig are helping add ingredients. Mouse adds four tomatoes, Cow adds five potatoes, and Pig adds…six galoshes?! Is that wise, Pig? Young readers will be so busy giggling at Pig’s antics, they won’t even realize they are counting, too. A twist ending and irresistible characters will make this a favorite read-aloud.
Title:Is That Wise, Pig?Format:Paper over BoardProduct dimensions:40 pages, 9 × 9 × 0.4 inShipping dimensions:9 × 9 × 0.4 inPublished:September 13, 2016Publisher:Beach Lane BooksLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:1416985824

ISBN - 13:9781416985822

Appropriate for ages: 4


Editorial Reviews

Children will be delighted with this silly variation of the traditional “Stone Soup” story. Several animals add ingredients to make a big pot of soup, but Pig brings some seemingly strange items, such as umbrellas and galoshes. When Pig brings his offerings, the other animals ask, “Is that wise, Pig?” Young readers will all know that his silly donations are not wise at all and will laugh at his poor choices. But in the end, Pig’s choices are wise indeed. This book is depicted in the author’s familiar style: large, cartoonlike illustrations with heavy black outlines cover the pages, and the text is provided via speech bubbles. The ingredients are also presented as a counting lesson: “one onion, two cabbages,” and so on. Young readers will be easily engaged by the ridiculous pig and appealing illustrations and will be drawn into the subtle counting exercise. VERDICT This read-aloud begs for extended activities, such as having children make (draw, paint, or cut) their own contributions to a communal pot of soup for the group. Recommended for all collections.