Reference without Referents by R. M. SainsburyReference without Referents by R. M. Sainsbury

Reference without Referents

byR. M. Sainsbury

Paperback | October 11, 2007

Pricing and Purchase Info


Earn 323 plum® points

Prices and offers may vary in store


In stock online

Ships free on orders over $25

Not available in stores


Reference is a central topic in philosophy of language, and has been the main focus of discussion about how language relates to the world. R. M. Sainsbury sets out a new approach to the concept, which promises to bring to an end some long-standing debates in semantic theory. There is a single category of referring expressions, all of which deserve essentially the same kind of semantic treatment. Included in this category are both singular and plural referring expressions ('Aristotle', 'The Pleiades'), complex and non-complex referring expressions ('The President of theUSA in 1970', 'Nixon'), and empty and non-empty referring expressions ('Vulcan', 'Neptune'). Referring expressions are to be described semantically by a reference condition, rather than by being associated with a referent. In arguing for these theses, Sainsbury's book promises to end the fruitlessoscillation between Millian and descriptivist views. Millian views insist that every name has a referent, and find it hard to give a good account of names which appear not to have referents, or at least are not known to do so, like ones introduced through error ('Vulcan'), ones where it is disputedwhether they have a bearer ('Patanjali') and ones used in fiction. Descriptivist theories require that each name be associated with some body of information. These theories fly in the face of the fact names are useful precisely because there is often no overlap of information among speakers andhearers. The alternative position for which the book argues is firmly non-descriptivist, though it also does not require a referent. A much broader view can be taken of which expressions are referring expressions: not just names and pronouns used demonstratively, but also some complex expressionsand some anaphoric uses of pronouns. Sainsbury's approach brings reference into line with truth: no one would think that a semantic theory should associate a sentence with a truth value, but it is commonly held that a semantic theory should associate a sentence with a truth condition, a condition which an arbitrary state of the worldwould have to satisfy in order to make the sentence true. The right analogy is that a semantic theory should associate a referring expression with a reference condition, a condition which an arbitrary object would have to satisfy in order to be the expression's referent. Lucid and accessible, and written with a minimum of technicality, Sainsbury's book also includes a useful historical survey. It will be of interest to those working in logic, mind, and metaphysics as well as essential reading for philosophers of language.
R.M. Sainsbury is in the Department of Philosophy, University of Texas at Austin.
Title:Reference without ReferentsFormat:PaperbackDimensions:288 pages, 9.21 × 6.14 × 0.63 inPublished:October 11, 2007Publisher:Oxford University PressLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:0199230404

ISBN - 13:9780199230402

Look for similar items by category:


Table of Contents

Preface1. A short history of theories of names2. Framework issues3. Proper names4. Pronouns: anaphora and demonstration5. Complex and plural referring expressions6. Existence and fiction7. Mental reference and individual conceptsBibliography