Strategic Impasse: Offense, Defense, And Deterrence Theory And Practice

Hardcover | August 1, 1989

byStephen J. Cimbala

not yet rated|write a review
There is probably no area of more crucial concern nor one more subject to possible misunderstanding and riddled with paradox than nuclear weapons and their use, not only in war, but as deterrents to war. In Strategic Impasse, Cimbala examines the critical issues, problems, and paradoxes inherent in the current nuclear situation. It is from a fundamental contradiction--the usefulness of nuclear weapons versus the undesirability of nuclear war--that nuclear deadlock arises. Their usefulness as deterrents is based on their destructive potential and the balance of power in Europe cannot be adjusted until the inflexible, bipolar "balance of terror" is addressed. Ironically, superpower sovereignty in nuclear first strike/retaliation capability, shared across the divided East-West political buffer zone, created the impetus for improvements in "conventional" warfare. To the extent war can be contained below the nuclear threshold, conventional weaponry contributes to "deterrence by denial." One difficulty lies in the improbability of completely isolating the nuclear from the conventional battlefield in a European scenario. Also, a level of superpower force perceived to be adequate in peacetime might prove to be an inadequate intrawar deterrent. Because of the underdevelopment of conceptual frameworks, "credible deterrence"--the creation of nuclear campaigns designed to prevent war--remains conjectural. Highly usable weapons require a command system that can provide for simultaneous fighting and escalation, but escalation beyond a certain level conflicts with control and therefore usability. In turn, low expectations of weapon usability may weaken deterrence. In Gorbachev's "defensivesufficiency," forces for aggression and surprise attack would be diminished, while forces for defense would be strengthened. The problem lies not only in differentiating between offensive and defensive weaponry but in achieving a consensus on such a definition by NATO's member countries. The book is divided into three parts: the first section, "Issues of Theory and Strategy," scrutinizes the relationship between offense and defense and examines SDI and more inclusive strategic defense matters. It also questions the connection between policy objectives and force, and explores the "complication of externalities," such as relations with allies. In section two, "Stretching Deterrence," Cimbala reviews the "operational art" likely to be employed by the Soviets in a conventionally fought European war and defines and appraises the "sensor-cyber" revolution in technology and its impacts on preferred strategies. The final part, "Beyond Deterrence," considers war termination scenarios and related issues, including sociopolitical aspects, surveys the part nuclear weapons play in superpower competition in the Third World, and explains how issues of sovereignty effect deterrence, avoidance, and future super power relations. Strategic Impasse will enable scholars and students of military affairs as well as political scientists and government officials to see beyond current "nuclear rhetoric" and to make informed judgments on an issue that fundamentally affects this nation's and the world's future.

Pricing and Purchase Info

$111.28 online
$124.50 list price (save 10%)
In stock online
Ships free on orders over $25

From the Publisher

There is probably no area of more crucial concern nor one more subject to possible misunderstanding and riddled with paradox than nuclear weapons and their use, not only in war, but as deterrents to war. In Strategic Impasse, Cimbala examines the critical issues, problems, and paradoxes inherent in the current nuclear situation. It is ...

Format:HardcoverDimensions:287 pages, 9.41 × 7.24 × 0.98 inPublished:August 1, 1989Publisher:GREENWOOD PRESS INC.

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:031326516X

ISBN - 13:9780313265167

Look for similar items by category:

Customer Reviews of Strategic Impasse: Offense, Defense, And Deterrence Theory And Practice

Reviews

Extra Content

Editorial Reviews

?The notion of impasse' in the title springs from the paradox that nuclear weapons are politically useful whereas nuclear war is not. Cimbala's treatise on the implications of modern weapons technology and military doctrine is an important work, somewhat reminiscent of Bernard Brodie's War and Politics. (Alas, Brodie and Clausewitz are rarely mentioned but most of the important recent scholarship in strategic affairs and civil military relations is carefully considered. Among the issues delineated is the problem of how nuclear war, and what Cimbala labels "amorphous" wars, can be terminated. The latter term covers a category ranging from limited, low-intensity conflict through more conventional combat, the most likely types of future US military involvement. The discussion of nuclear war examines deterrence and meanings of rationality in big power confrontations. One might hope that the astonishing developments of 1989 within the disintegrating Soviet empire will make much of Cimbala's text irrelevant, but that is doubtful. For the foreseeable future this book represents a very useful analysis of America's strategic military perspective in relation to the USSR and to a heterogeneous international system with increasingly dangerous armaments. . . . Recommended for universities and colleges with national security and military studies, upper-division undergraduates and above.?-Choice