Why Lawyers Derail Justice: Probing the Roots of Legal Injustices

Paperback | June 11, 2004

byJohn C. Anderson

not yet rated|write a review

The "rule of law" has become a shibboleth of American democracy, but the emphasis on procedural and abstract rather than substantive justice that is embedded both in the workings of our judicial system and in the writings of our leading philosophers of law, John Anderson argues, has led to much real injustice. This book draws inspiration from Aristotle's notion of "natural justice" found in communities based on ties of friendship to point the way toward a more humane practice of law.

Starting with concrete examples of injustice produced in our legal system, the author examines the distorting effects of legal argumentation and strategy on affirmative action, overzealous prosecutions, abusive enforcement of the tax code, sexual harassment litigation, and many other issues troubling our society. The jurisprudence of Ronald Dworkin, with his notion of a "community of principle," is identified as best articulating the justification for our current system and is subjected to a thorough critique from an Aristotelian perspective. Kant's "kingdom of ends" is located at the root of rights-based notions of justice and is also argued to be inadequate because it lacks the flexibility allowed by the classical understanding of epieikeia (equity).

What issues from this investigation of the faults of our present legal regime is a set of proposals for reform that include abolition of the legal profession and term limits for judges as well as politicians.

Pricing and Purchase Info

$52.95

In stock online
Ships free on orders over $25

From the Publisher

The "rule of law" has become a shibboleth of American democracy, but the emphasis on procedural and abstract rather than substantive justice that is embedded both in the workings of our judicial system and in the writings of our leading philosophers of law, John Anderson argues, has led to much real injustice. This book draws inspirati...

John C. Anderson holds a law degree and a doctoral degree in philosophy from The Catholic University of America, and practiced law for five years in Washington, D. C. An independent scholar, he now works for the Army.

other books by John C. Anderson

Supernatural Forces in Spiritual Warfare: Wrestling with Dark Angels
Supernatural Forces in Spiritual Warfare: Wrestling wit...

Kobo ebook|Oct 16 2012

$17.19 online$22.30list price(save 22%)
Discourse Perspectives on Organizational Communication
Discourse Perspectives on Organizational Communication

Kobo ebook|Oct 16 2011

$88.59 online$114.99list price(save 22%)
Exploring and Explaining Diversity in Agricultural Technology
Exploring and Explaining Diversity in Agricultural Tech...

Kobo ebook|Aug 29 2014

$31.89 online$41.36list price(save 22%)
see all books by John C. Anderson
Format:PaperbackDimensions:252 pages, 9 × 6 × 0.57 inPublished:June 11, 2004Publisher:Penn State University PressLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:027102514X

ISBN - 13:9780271025148

Customer Reviews of Why Lawyers Derail Justice: Probing the Roots of Legal Injustices

Reviews

Extra Content

Editorial Reviews

“One shortcoming, if it may be called that, is that Anderson fails to situate the American legal system within the broader liberal political tradition. Though he is not explicit about it, Anderson’s real target, it seems to me, is the liberal political tradition—from at least Locke forward—of which the legal system, in its present state, is but one institutional manifestation of one form of liberalism. Notwithstanding this criticism, Anderson’s account of jurisprudential legalism and his critique of Dworkin’s jurisprudence alone make the book well worth the attention of all who, contrary to the sentiments of Justice Holmes, believe that law and justice need not be antithetical to each other.”—Kevin Pybas, Justice System Journal