Without Justification

Paperback | January 5, 2007

byJonathan Sutton

not yet rated|write a review

In the contentious debate among contemporary epistemologists and philosophers regarding justification, there is one consensus: justification is distinct from knowledge; there are justified beliefs that do not amount to knowledge, even if all instances of knowledge are instances of justified belief. In Without Justification, Jonathan Sutton forcefully opposes this claim. He proposes instead that justified belief simply is knowledge -- not because there is more knowledge than has been supposed, but because there are fewer justified beliefs. There are, he argues, no false justified beliefs.

Sutton suggests that the distinction between justified belief and knowledge is drawn only in contemporary epistemology, and suggests furter that classic philosophers of both ancient and modern times would not have questioned the idea that justification is identical to knowledge.

Sutton argues both that we do not (perhaps even cannot) have a serviceable notion of justification that is distinct from knowledge and that we do not need one. We can get by better in epistemology, he writes, without it. Sutton explores the topics of testimony and evidence, and proposes an account of these two key epistemological topics that relies on the notion of knowledge alone. He also addresses inference (both deductive and inductive), internalism versus externalism in epistemology, functionalism, the paradox of the preface, and the lottery paradox. Sutton argues that all of us--philosopher and nonphilosopher alike--should stick to what we know; we should believe something only if we know it to be so. Further, we should not believe what someone tells us unless we know that he knows what he is talking about. These views are radical, he argues, only in the context of contemporary epistemology's ill-founded distinction between knowledge and justification.

Pricing and Purchase Info

$33.94 online
$33.95 list price
In stock online
Ships free on orders over $25

From the Publisher

In the contentious debate among contemporary epistemologists and philosophers regarding justification, there is one consensus: justification is distinct from knowledge; there are justified beliefs that do not amount to knowledge, even if all instances of knowledge are instances of justified belief. In Without Justification, Jonathan S...

Jonathan Sutton is Assistant Professor of Philosophy at Auburn University.

other books by Jonathan Sutton

Oracle 219 Success Secrets - 219 Most Asked Questions On Oracle - What You Need To Know
Oracle 219 Success Secrets - 219 Most Asked Questions O...

Kobo ebook|Feb 20 2014

$19.29 online$24.99list price(save 22%)
Format:PaperbackDimensions:208 pages, 9 × 6 × 0.5 inPublished:January 5, 2007Publisher:The MIT PressLanguage:English

The following ISBNs are associated with this title:

ISBN - 10:026269347X

ISBN - 13:9780262693479

Look for similar items by category:

Customer Reviews of Without Justification

Reviews

Extra Content

Editorial Reviews

While Timothy Williamson's slogan is 'Knowledge First', Jonathan Sutton's is 'Knowledge First and Last'. Sutton's slogan is shorthand for a view that bucks a central trend in modern epistemology: Sutton denies that there is a viable notion of justification that is distinct from the notion of knowledge itself. In arguing that we should do without a traditional notion of justification in doing epistemology, Sutton takes us through some fascinating case studies regarding testimony and inference. Without Justification is a lucid, elegant, and important work, one of the best books in recent epistemology.